1. Assets and Liabilities Key Parameter |
Year |
Asset(Lacs) |
Liabilities(Lacs) |
Net Worth(Lacs) |
Book Value |
D/E |
RONW |
Receiveable days |
FY13 |
2,713.59 |
2,226.21 |
487.38 |
27 |
4.56 |
9.34% |
44 |
FY14 |
3,007.50 |
2,462.60 |
544.9 |
30 |
4.51 |
10.56% |
30 |
FY15 |
2,852.49 |
2,266.60 |
585.89 |
33 |
3.86 |
7.00% |
30 |
FY16 |
3,416.94 |
2,562.94 |
854 |
16 |
3.00 |
31.39% |
29 |
FY17 |
3,493.92 |
2,559.22 |
934.7 |
17 |
2.73 |
8.63% |
66 |
9MFY18 |
3,774.16 |
2,613.56 |
1,160.60 |
16 |
2.25 |
19.46% |
71 |
Post Issue |
|
|
2171.48 |
22 |
1.2 |
|
|
2. Profit n Loss Key Parameter
(i) The
Revenue of the company in last 5 years ( FY13to 9MFY18) is
33.71 Cr,
33.55Cr,
34.05Cr,
36.82,
39.03 Cr and
38.61 Cr respectively.
(ii) The
PAT of the company in last 5 years ( FY13 to 6MFY18) is
45.53 Lacs,
57.52Lacs,
40.99 Lacs,
2.68 Cr ,
80.7 Lacs and
2.25 Cr respectively.
(iii) The
EBITDA Margins of the company for FY13(
10%), FY14(
11%), FY15(
11%) ,FY16(
14%), FY17(
11%) and 9MF18(
14%) .
(iv) P/B(post issue)=
21.63(at cutoff price of 36)
(v) Annualized EPS(post issue)=
3
(vi) Annualized P/E(post issue)=
12 at the cutoff price of 36
3. Cash Flow Statement(all figures in Lacs) |
Particulars |
FY17 |
FY16 |
FY15 |
FY14 |
FY13 |
(i) Net Cash Generated from Operation |
270.57 |
468.16 |
94.12 |
154.71 |
350.22 |
(ii) Net Cash Generated from Investment |
-150.88 |
-261.12 |
-63.5 |
-192.27 |
-173.37 |
(iii) Net Cash Generated from Financing Activity |
-130.65 |
-211.95 |
-76.87 |
46.05 |
-155.2 |
(iv) Total[ (i)+(ii)+(iii) ] |
-10.96 |
-4.91 |
-46.25 |
8.49 |
21.65 |
Key Observations
(i)The Company is
regular defaulter in depositing
TDS to the Govt and hence company has received prosecution notice under Income Tax Act, 1961. The total outstanding TDS is around
38 Lacs. This is a serious offence where you are deducting TDS and not submitting to the govt.
(ii)As on 31st Dec 2017, the company owes around
4.77 Cr to
113 creditors. Moreover, the company owes more than 5% of the total consolidated trade payables from 2 creditors.
(iii)The Company export nearly
40% of their products to
Dubai and
Iraq. So fluctuation in currency is a big factor to consider in this company.
(iv)The Promoter
Group Entity &
Group Company namely, Sonam Tradelink LLP, is in the same business as Sonam Clock Limited, which can create conflict of interest in future.
(v)Avearge cost of Acquisition to the promoters
Sr.no, No. of shares held , Average cost of acquisition
Mr. Jayeshbhai Chhabildas Shah, 62,39,200, 2.43
Mrs. Deepaben Jayeshbhai Shah 4,80,000, 2.50
(vi)The
Revenue and
PAT of the company in FY17 were only
39.03 Cr and 80 Lacs against 9MFY18
Revenue and PAT of
38.61 Cr and
2.25 Cr respectively
. This shows Company has achieved amazing growth of 3x times in PAT under falling revenue speaks nothing less than manipulation of books just before the IPO. The inventory has gone up which results into less expense and hence more profit.
(vii)The Company has muted revenue growth of 3% in last 5 years.
(viii)Though P/E at 12 looks reasonable on earning of annualized 9MFY18. However, as we discussed earlier that the PAT of 2.25 Cr on decreased revenue looks fishy , so if we consider
FY17 PAT of
80 lacs to calculate P/E , it comes out to be
45 post issue which looks overvalued.
Though revenue of the company has gone up from 36 cr to 39 cr from FY16 to FY17 but increase in receivables days from 29 to 66 days clearly indicates that company is selling products on credit of 66 days almost double from previous years, which is quite negative for the companies with the large working capital requirement.
It is a big avoid. No point of applying in a company which has big corporate governance issues like No filling of TDS , increase in trade payables and many more issues.
The recently announced Customs Duty on Imported clocks as well as other new regulatory impositions by the Government, such as introduction of GST and the likely to be announced E-way will help a great deal in eliminating from the scene those businesses that were operating nefariously by evading payment of taxes Organised Players grow their businesses and progressively move forward